Paskapoo sandstone alternative: Duna
Paskapoo is the yellow sandstone Calgary was rebuilt in after the fire of 1886. The city’s quarries closed in 1915, and in 2010 the Alberta Geological Survey knew of no Paskapoo quarry in production. Duna is a tan calcareous sandstone from our own quarry. Under European (EN) tests it takes 73 MPa in compression, the load it carries before it breaks. We propose it for new build next to those buildings, and it is in place on a hotel facade in Barcelona and as setts in Greenwich Park, in London.
Paskapoo sandstone
- Type:
- Paleocene fluvial sandstone (Paskapoo Formation)
- Origin:
- Calgary and its surroundings, Alberta (Canada)
- Colour:
- Yellow to buff, sometimes with bluish hues. The Calgary stone is the most yellow
The last Calgary quarries closed in 1915 and the city grew around them. To rehabilitate Historic City Hall, completed in 2020, the City looked at reopening a local quarry and ended up buying sandstone in Poland, Spain and the United States, about 1,350 tonnes of new stone. The project’s conservation standards required replacement stone that was physically and visually compatible with the original.
Duna
A tan tone with orange hues and a calcareous grain. We recommend it for ashlar, cladding and setts.
View stoneTechnical comparison
| Property | Paskapoo sandstone | Duna |
|---|---|---|
| Petrographic family | Fluvial sandstone of quartz, feldspar and dark minerals (Paskapoo Formation, Paleocene) | Calcarenite (calcareous sandstone) |
| The make-up differs. Both are sandstones and their colour is close. | ||
| Colour | Yellow to buff, the Calgary stone yellow | Tan with orange hues |
| Paskapoo in place carries over a hundred years of patina. | ||
| Test standards | 1916 tests (Parks), compiled by the Alberta Geological Survey in 2010 | European standards (EN), no ASTM tests |
| Apparent density | About 2,100 kg/m³ (published data, yellow Calgary stone) | 2,410 kg/m³ |
| Compressive strength | 41 MPa dry and 27 MPa wet | 73 MPa |
| The Paskapoo values are 1916 tests, converted from pounds per square inch, with methods that are not equivalent to EN standards. | ||
| Flexural strength | 2.7 MPa (1916 transverse test) | 8.5 MPa |
| Freeze-thaw | No comparable test, described as vulnerable to freeze-thaw | Bending from 8.5 to 7.9 MPa after 56 cycles |
| Porosity | 21.7 % pore space (1916) | 12.6 % open porosity |
| Abrasion | No comparable test | 25 mm |
| Slip resistance | No comparable test | 94 dry, 78 wet (SRV) |
| European pendulum test: the higher the value, the more grip underfoot. | ||
| Finishes | Sawn or rock-faced ashlar, lintels, sills and carvings | Sawn, honed, sandblasted, bush-hammered (also fine and coarse), brushed, chiselled, split and Rubio's Special; no flamed finish |
| Supply | Calgary quarries closed since 1915, none in production for Paskapoo in 2010 | Own quarry and factory in Les Borges Blanques (Lleida, Spain) |
Equivalence sheet (PDF)
This comparison on one page, with the technical data and sources, to share with your team or client.
We recommend Duna for new build and extensions next to Calgary’s historic sandstone, as ashlar, cladding and setts. Its calcareous grain does not reproduce the salt-and-pepper look of Paskapoo. For replacing pieces on a protected building, the decision lies with the conservation team, and we send them samples and Duna’s test documentation to assess. On plinths and in areas where salt is spread in winter, the project’s technical team should review the test data before specifying it.
The colour of Paskapoo and of Duna
According to the Alberta Geological Survey, Paskapoo ranges from yellow to buff and occasionally shows bluish tones. Its colour changes with years of exposure, and the stone that came out of the Calgary quarries is the most yellow. Duna has a tan tone with orange hues. On Historic City Hall the new stone stood out at first from the original, and the City expected it to lighten as it weathered. Closeness of tone is checked with a sample held against the facade, in local light.
A porous sandstone in the Alberta climate
The Paskapoo Formation was laid down by rivers between 66 and 56 million years ago. Its sandstone combines, in roughly equal parts, grains of quartz, feldspar and dark minerals, which give it a salt-and-pepper look, bound by a carbonate and clay cement. A geologist at the Alberta Geological Survey explains that, because the rock is young, its pores never filled completely with cement, which makes it quite porous and vulnerable to frost. The province’s heritage branch adds intense sunlight, drying winds and de-icing salts, and notes that mortar and detailing also shape how the stone performs over time. On Calgary’s Historic City Hall, 97 % of the 15,522 pieces of sandstone had to be repaired.
Duna test data, 1916 Paskapoo figures and ASTM standards
The Duna figures come from tests carried out to European (EN) standards. In bending, with the piece resting on two supports, it breaks at 8.5 MPa, and after 56 freeze-thaw cycles at 7.9 MPa, 7 % lower. It has 12.6 % open porosity, which is the share of its volume made up of pores that water can reach. For Paskapoo there are only tests from 1916, compiled by the Alberta Geological Survey in 2010. The yellow Calgary stone gave about 41 MPa dry in compression and 21.7 % pore space. These are methods from over a century ago and are not equivalent to the European ones. Nor do we have ASTM tests for Duna, the standards normally used in Canada and the United States, so its figures should always be read as EN results.
Recommended uses for Duna next to historic buildings
We recommend Duna for ashlar, facade cladding and setts. In Barcelona, the Hotel Universal facade is clad in 4 cm Duna. It was chosen because it recalls the Montjuïc sandstone, whose quarry is exhausted. In London, the 2024 heritage restoration of Greenwich Park uses it as setts. At Mas de la Costa, in Teruel, the arches, mouldings and outdoor paving are in Duna, with pitched and rustic finishes. We cut ashlar and facade pieces at our factory in Les Borges Blanques, Lleida. We supply the stone, and fixing it is the work of the project’s masonry team.
Frequently asked questions
Is Paskapoo sandstone still quarried in Calgary?
No. The city’s quarries stopped working in 1915 and are now surrounded by neighbourhoods. To rehabilitate Historic City Hall, the City looked at reopening one and ended up buying the sandstone outside Canada. Alberta’s 2010 building stone inventory lists no active Paskapoo quarry.
Does Duna have ASTM test results?
No. Duna is tested to European (EN) standards. If your project needs ASTM results, say so in your enquiry.
Are there buildings in Calgary with Duna?
No. Its reference projects are in Europe, among them the setts in Greenwich Park, London, and the Hotel Universal in Barcelona.
Do you quote for projects in Canada?
Yes, we quote for projects in Canada.
All eight Rubio sandstones, their test data and the other published comparisons, on one page.
Spanish sandstone for UK projectsCheck availability and lead time
Tell us which building you are working next to or which tone you need to follow, the pieces you need (ashlar, cladding or setts) and the approximate area. We will prepare Duna samples with their declaration of performance.
- Availability, lead time and price with your measurements
- Physical sample free of charge for professionals
- Technical datasheet with test values
